27 Lobster And Surf Shack - Let’s call it what it is. 27 Lobster And Surf Shack, at 2095 Montauk Hwy, is a good place to pull. The crowd is good looking and the ambiance is sexy, so if you can’t meet someone here, well, keep drinking and try again. Liquid courage always helps. Look, we’re not guaranteeing anything, but at 27 Lobster And Surf Shack you should have plenty of options.